In this video, Felix, a leading horticultural expert from Gurney's Seed & Nursery, talks about when to pick pawpaw fruit and how to pick the fruit. Pawpaw fruit can be picked anywhere from early September - late October, depending on where you're growing your pawpaw tree. The interior of the pawpaw fruit should be soft and pulpy, like custard; when you squeeze the fruit, it should have some give. Browse all Gardening How-To Videos