Product review for Gurney's Giant Magic Hybrid Pumpkin Overall Rating: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers Sort Reviews: Newest | Oldest | Highest Rating | Lowest Rating   :: Viewing page 1 of 2  -  Wednesday, February 07, 2007 Great! Reviewed By: Shane (Roseville, California) Gurney's Giant Magic Hybrid Pumpkin is a must! We got 4 good size pumpkins off of one vine. They are a very nice size and shape. They also make excellent pumpkin pies.  -  Tuesday, April 17, 2007 Success!! Reviewed By: Blake (Defiance, Ohio) Excellent pumpkin!! I had two pumpkins that surpassed 40lbs! Excellent shape and color. A must for any pumpkin enthusiast! Overall, I had 10 plants produce 60+ pumpkins! Good Luck!  -  Wednesday, October 10, 2007 Grew very well! Reviewed By: JUSTIN (GRENWOOD, IN) Grew very well. Had several 15-20 lbs pumpkins per plant. I plan to order more next year and expend my patch.  -  Monday, February 18, 2008 Hybrid Pumpkin Reviewed By: Elizabeth (Buffalo, New York) Planted three of these seeds. This was my very first garden and lucky me, I got a total of three pumpkins. The dog got to one of them and killed it, but the other two turned out great! Beautiful blooms as well. Definately a safe bet! My pumpkins lasted forever too! One of them sat on my windowsill until mid-january after being plucked from the vine in late September. Excellent choice, good luck!!  -  Thursday, March 27, 2008 THE BEST PUMPKINS Reviewed By: Elizabeth (North Grafton, MA) I have bought these seeds for the last 3 years in a row. They consistently produce big almost perfectly round pumpkins. The fruit is typically 15 to 20 pounds. They are the best ones I have found!